Socrates first accusers and the athenian law

In the comic play, The Clouds BCAristophanes represents Socrates as a sophistic philosopher who teaches the young man Pheidippides how to formulate arguments that justify striking and beating his father. Socrates left no written works, but his student and friend, Platowrote Socratic dialoguesfeaturing Socrates as the protagonist. He then defected back to Athens after successfully persuading the Athenians that Persia would come to their aid against Sparta though Persia had no intention of doing so. Another possible source of resentment were the political views that he and his associates were thought to have embraced.

Socrates first accusers and the athenian law

The Royal Stoa in Athens, where Meletus presented his charges against Socrates Meletus, the "Principal Accuser" Meletus, a poet, initiated the prosecution against Socrates, although most scholars consider him to a "puppet" of the best-known and most influential of the three accusers, Anytus.

The affidavit sworn out by Meletus made two related charges against Socrates: During the first three hours of trial, Meletus and the other two accusers each mounted a small stage in the law court in the center of Athens to deliver speeches to the jury making the case for the guilt of Socrates.

No record of Meletus's speech survives. According to the partisan account of Plato in the Apology, Socrates--during his three-hour defense--entered into an exchange with Meletus and succeeded in making him appear rather dim-witted.

For example, Plato reports Socrates trapping Meletus into saying "I say that you do not believe in any gods at all" and then exposes his accusation as nonsensical.

Meletus' motivation in bringing charges against Socrates is a matter of considerable debate. It may have sprung either from his religious fanaticism or his anger over Socrates's association with the Thirty Tyrants.

It is also possible that he was to some degree upset with the low opinion of Socrates for poets. In Plato's Gorgias, Socrates accuses poets and orators of flattery and says that they move only women, children, and slaves.

Greek historian Diogenes Laertius, writing in the first half of the third century, reported that after the execution of Socrates "Athenians felt such remorse" that they banished Meletus from their city. This report is often questioned, however, as it is inconsistent with other earlier writings which offer no such indication of widespread regret over the jury's actions in B.

Anytus, the Power Behind the Prosecution Anytus, a powerful middle-class politician from a family of tanners, is generally considered to have been the driving force behind the prosecution of Socrates.

Prior to his political career in Athens, Anytus served as a general in the Peloponnesian War. Blamed for losing Pylos to the Spartans, Anytus faced charges of treason, but was acquitted--with the help of a well-placed jury bribe, according to several accounts.

Anytus gained influence in Athens by playing a leading role in the democratic revolt of B. Despite having lost property and money during the eight months the tyrannical oligarchy ruled Athens, Anytus made no attempt to compensate himself for his losses, thus earning additional favor with the public.

Anytus supported the Amnesty of Eucleides in that prohibited prosecution of offenses occurring during or before the Rule of Thirty. Anytus' motivation in prosecuting Socrates is believed to have been based on his concern that the Socrates's criticism of Athenian institutions endangered the democracy that Athens had so recently regained.

Socrates, who was associated with several persons viewed as responsible for the overthrow of Athenian democracy, made no secret of his disdain for politicians such as Anytus. Even after democracy was restored, he continued to ridicule such centerpieces of Athenian democracy as the selection of leaders by majority vote.

Plato's Meno offers some possible clues as to the animosity between Anytus and Socrates. In the Meno, Plato reports that Socrates's argument that the great statesmen of Athenian history have nothing to offer in terms of an understanding of virtue enrages Anytus.

Plato quotes Anytus as warning Socrates: Socrates had a relationship with the son of Anytus. Plato quotes Socrates as saying, "I has a brief association with the son of Anytus, and I found him not lacking in spirit.

Anytus almost certainly disapproved of his son's relationship with Socrates. Adding to Anytus's displeasure must have been the advice Socrates gave to his son. According to Xenophon, Socrates urged his son not to "continue in the servile occupation [tanning hides] that his father has provided for him.

He is described as "an orator," another profession Socrates held in especially low regard. Socrates contended that orators were less concerned with the pursuit of truth than in using their oratorical skills to obtain power and influence. Diogenes Laertius, writing in the third century C.

Laertius's use of the word "demagogue" suggests that Lycon may have been a supporter of the common man in Socrates' view, perhaps, a rabble-rouser. As such, he likely perceived Socrates as a threat to the democracy he highly valued.

Lycon may also have blamed Socrates for a homosexual relationship between his son, Autolycus, and a friend of Socrates--three decades older than Autolycus--named Callias.

In Plato's Symposium, Socrates, during a dinner party, praises the "higher love" of Callias for the much-younger Autolycus.Socrate's First Accusers and Athenian Law.

Criminal Procedure in Ancient Athens and in the Trial of Socrates

Of all confrontations in political philosophy, the biggest is. the conflict between philosophy and politics.

The problem remains. Socrates, himself, speaks out the accusers. charges by saying 'Socrates does injustice and is meddlesome, by.3/5(2). Socrates, himself, speaks out the accuserscharges by saying “Socrates does injustice and is meddlesome, byinvestigating the things under the earth and the heavenly things, and bymaking the weaker the stronger and by teaching others these things” (Plato,19b;c).

Socrate's First Accusers and Athenian Law Of all confrontations in political philosophy, the biggest is the conflict between. philosophy and politics. The problem remains making philosophy friendly to politics.

Socrates first accusers and the athenian law

The questioning of authoritative opinions is not easily accomplished nor is that realm of philosophy - the pursuit of wisdom. Socrates v. the First Accusers: Socrates says that people such as Aristophanes persuaded many of the jurors and accused him falsely, saying that “there is a man called Socrates, a wise man, a student of all things in the sky and below the earth, who makes the worse argument the stronger” (18b-c), and who “teaches these same things to.

Socrates’ ;First Accusers and Athenian Law Of all confrontations in political philosophy, the biggest is the conflict between philosophy and politics. The problem remains making philosophy friendly to politics. The questioning of authoritative opinions is not easily accomplished nor is that realm of philosophy – ;the pursuit of wisdom.

To discourage frivolous suits, however, Athenian law imposed a heavy fine on plaintiffs who failed to obtain at least one fifth of the jury’s votes, as Socrates later points out (Apology 36a–b).

Unlike closely timed jury trials, pre-trial examinations encouraged questions to and by the litigants, to make the legal issues more precise.

Apology (Plato) - Wikipedia